How sanctuary cities actually work

共有
埋め込みコード
  • に公開 2017/04/25
  • President Trump says he wants to strip funding from so-called "sanctuary cities," but what exactly do these cities do?
    Subscribe to our channel! goo.gl/0bsAjO
    The map at 4:26 comes from the Immigrant Legal Resource Center (www.ilrc.org/local-enforcement-map)
    Cities and counties that limit their cooperation with federal immigration agents are sometimes called "sanctuaries," but the word doesn't actually have any legal meaning. However, because the constitution prohibits the federal government from making states enforce its laws, cities, counties, and other local jurisdictions have lots of freedom to ignore, or comply with, requests from federal agencies like ICE to detain undocumented immigrants for deportation.
    Vox.com is a news website that helps you cut through the noise and understand what's really driving the events in the headlines. Check out www.vox.com to get up to speed on everything from Kurdistan to the Kim Kardashian app.
    Check out our full video catalog: goo.gl/IZONyE
    Follow Vox on Twitter: goo.gl/XFrZ5H
    Or on Facebook: goo.gl/U2g06o

コメント数 • 5 973

  • sea monkey
    sea monkey 10 時間 前

    The feds just dumped their decisions about immigrants onto local policemen

  • FIRST LIMITED
    FIRST LIMITED 11 時間 前

    There's so many things wrongs with this video it's Hillary that someone would find this informative

  • FIRST LIMITED
    FIRST LIMITED 11 時間 前

    0:27 you are safe, to vote Democrat. This honestly looks like republicans are the parents and Democrats are the children and the illegsls is a new pet that they want caus it's cute and helpless and the kid just wants to give it everything it needs while the parents think about everything else, paying for the food and medicine also having to spend that time to help the kid understand responsibility. Kid ends up playing with it a lot for a while and slowly little by little they move onto a different thing. ( Before you get triggered, I'm Hispanic who has to identify white and don't make everything about myself and I mean no offense to anyone just simply stating my opinion we can discuss about it like civilized people or just throw ad hominems at me and get nowhere the choice is yours )

  • Coouge
    Coouge 日 前

    Omg so biased lol

  • Jeffery Allen
    Jeffery Allen 2 日 前

    The entire premise is your ignoring the law because you dont like it. That logic wouldnt fly under any other circumstance.

  • MrCTruck
    MrCTruck 3 日 前

    “You’re safe in Chicago” unless you live in the Southside

  • KMAC Radio
    KMAC Radio 5 日 前

    Total liberal left democrat bullshit.

  • Abhishek Sunkara
    Abhishek Sunkara 5 日 前

    Without proper documentation immigrants can never hold good (lucrative) jobs. That will force them to pursue low paying (lower than minimum wage) jobs and be stuck in poverty. This also applies to the children who want to apply to colleges. And it might be powerful agent in turning them towards illegal jobs and maybe even minor crimes. I think every resident (of every country) should have proper documents. Most people are not refugees of war but just come to the states and never leave. I am not a US citizen but there are somethings where both parties (people) should agree upon.
    - Climate change (its real and its scary)
    - Taxation (tax the businesses and the rich please, most people do not deserve the money, its money making more money not their caliber)
    - Religion (Everyone please tone it down, and leave it out of schools and law making and yes tax the churches, temples etc)
    - Immigration (Enforce tough laws please, yes they are people but unless something is done US will soon be full of poor illegal immigrants)
    - Guns (Tone it down please, there are too many out there. Register yourself if you carry)
    - Political Correctness (Not necessary, everyone should speak their minds. This is a major reason why so many people are annoyed)
    - Women's rights (we do need to make women feel more empowered. I know some of you won't believe me but empowering women will empower the nation. There might be some some false cases but there are many more cases where women who have been assaulted do not get voice and are scared to come out.)

  • Alexander Bradley
    Alexander Bradley 6 日 前 +1

    Oh my god, if Sanctuary Cities are violent and terrible places, the comment section of vox Videos is the definition

  • ERIC SUN
    ERIC SUN 6 日 前

    Woo woo woo it all gone wrong when you said that thing about immigrants not wanting to report crime. I’m a Chinese immigrant to the uk and if some other ILLEGAL Chinese immigrant gets sent home, that doesn’t stop me from reporting to the police, because i am under the law. Since the illegal immigrant broke the law in the first place, it’s his/her fault that their vulnerable, because he/she is the one to break the law first.
    The libtard agenda on this channel is too obvious for me to continue watching. Bye

  • Jake M
    Jake M 8 日 前

    Seems like immigrants could avoid all of these problems if they would come in legally . Why is that hard to figure out ?

  • Robin Breeds
    Robin Breeds 10 日 前

    When it wiped out the middle class you just taken self back to middle ages lol

  • Lian T
    Lian T 10 日 前

    Very stupid US for allowing illegal immigrants to stay. Its like giving criminals safe haven. If I were a criminal I might do the biggest heist I can in my country and leave permanently for Chicago. I dont like the idea of allowing illegal immigrants to stay, and I am not even American
    It seems Dems are willing to sell US for money (vote)

  • GabeN The Great
    GabeN The Great 11 日 前

    Shocked you have not banned comments, yet like the rest of the filthy liberals you hate our great country

  • GabeN The Great
    GabeN The Great 11 日 前

    Every last crime from an illegal is a 100% preventable. If you say other wise please explain

  • HOF Collector
    HOF Collector 11 日 前

    Lmao. If you’re illegal you don’t belong here. Done. No need to try to entice the weak minded.

  • Sketch Assassin
    Sketch Assassin 13 日 前

    Can someone lead me towards the conservative perspective of this topic? I want to see the other side of this story.

  • TrutherTalk
    TrutherTalk 13 日 前 +4

    Sanctuary Cities Suck. Just like Vox.

  • Lets get to 5000 subscribers without a video!

    There is no proof that not being a sanctuary city will stop the illegal population from interacting with police. Police don't check in with the ICE database every time someone reports a crime. Sanctuary cities are just here because officials want votes. They are not here to increase interaction with police.

  • Alex Cesarz
    Alex Cesarz 14 日 前

    Why is vox saying "immigrants" will be afraid to call the police. FALSE! Illegal undocumented Aliens will be afraid to call the police. I'm a LEGAL immigrant. I know hundreds of people that are LEGAL immigrants. We would have no problem or have any fear of calling the police! STOP trying to mash the two terms as the same ! They're completely different ! Typical leftist tactics.

  • Eric Jones
    Eric Jones 14 日 前

    Kick them out. MAGA

  • Chris J
    Chris J 15 日 前

    "Illegal immigration helps our nation by draining billions upon billions of dollars every year, so what we really need is open boarders" - Vox

  • bob smith
    bob smith 22 日 前

    yep they work...work to make more DNC voters!

  • Matthew Cioffi
    Matthew Cioffi 23 日 前

    I don't understand. If the U.S. is so evil, unfair, and racist, why do people keep coming here? If it isn't, then STOP SAYING THAT IT IS!

  • ramon Alonzo
    ramon Alonzo 23 日 前

    "you safe in Washington dc"

  • Keith Stengel
    Keith Stengel 24 日 前

    Vox you are 1 sided and alwas been FAKE. NEWS

  • Drunk Llama
    Drunk Llama 26 日 前

    "You are safe in Chicago"
    xD

  • Zenniistuff
    Zenniistuff 26 日 前

    I thought Oklahoma would be very strict about immigration
    Cool.

  • Alex Ray
    Alex Ray 26 日 前

    A possible solution here might be to have police only report an illegal immigrant if that immigrant is being held for a significant crime.
    Barring police from asking about immigration status is also a good step as it could help illegal immigrants feel more secure in calling the police

  • Truly Living
    Truly Living 27 日 前

    “Left and right “ guys this is a human issue stop putting it in a box of perceptions

  • Lisa M
    Lisa M 27 日 前

    If you don't punish them, then how will you stop them from breaking the law and entering the country illegally? It causes worse crime if you don't do something about it. They are contributing to drug problems and creating a burden on the tax system.
    Drug smuggling, and the endless battle to stop it
    www.usatoday.com/border-wall/story/drug-trafficking-smuggling-cartels-tunnels/559814001/
    U.S. Appetite for Mexico’s Drugs Fuels Illegal Immigration
    www.nytimes.com/2017/04/04/us/politics/us-appetite-for-mexicos-drugs-fuels-illegal-immigration.html
    www.nationalreview.com/corner/crime-illegal-immigration/
    www.gao.gov/assets/320/316959.pdf
    According to GAO, in FY 2009 295,959 SCAAP criminal aliens, of whom approximately 227,600 are illegal aliens, were incarcerated in state jails and prisons. This is a 40 percent and 25 percent increase, respectively, in criminal-alien incarcerations in state jails and prisons since FY 2003.
    thehill.com/blogs/congress-blog/homeland-security/352869-the-cost-of-illegal-immigration-to-taxpayers-is-growing
    FAIR found that while illegal immigrants pay billions of dollars in taxes every year, they ultimately cost taxpayers more than seven times what they contribute. The study found that illegal immigrants pay almost $19 billion annually in combined federal, state and local taxes. This estimate is actually considerably higher than what many studies before this have suggested. However, the amount of taxes illegal immigrants pay is dwarfed by the considerable costs that they impose on American taxpayers: nearly $135 billion annually, creating a net deficit of $116 billion. The majority of the costs to taxpayers, $89 billion (66 percent), are borne at the local and state level. This means that American taxpayers are forced to bear the costs of the federal government’s failure to secure our borders every time they pay school taxes, local tolls, sales and excise taxes. It also means that illegal migrants get a lot of benefits that they don’t pay for.

  • smile444
    smile444 28 日 前

    interesting, i didn'r know about sanctuary citiesbbefore (i'm french, we don't have that at home, but a lot of the population support immigrants, giving food clothes and shelter)

    • smile444
      smile444 19 日 前

      Any event producing refugee on that scale is truly awful indeed. What exactly did you see in Paris ? Immigrants should bother tourists much...

    • Sonia Desai
      Sonia Desai 19 日 前 +1

      Smile 444-what is happening in France is terrible! Big difference between when I visited Paris before and after refugees came. Not just Paris but other parts of France too.

  • Jose Gonzalez
    Jose Gonzalez 28 日 前

    *ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS

  • Toxic Waste Radioactive

    Anyone supporting sanctuary cities and illegal aliens should be considered as traitors to the country
    We should use fear to deter illegal alien, make examples of them, make them suffer as much as possible without violating the constitution.

  • Ben and Natalie Mason

    Don’t deport a poor immigrant, it’s just rude

  • Aguila701
    Aguila701 ヶ月 前

    Whether the government wants to admit it or not, illegal immigrants already make up the fiber of life in the U.S. Choosing to turn against them is just like taking off blocks from a jenga tower. Something's going to come crashing down.

  • Aguila701
    Aguila701 ヶ月 前

    "Satanic worshippers" 🤣🤣

  • Joe Michaels
    Joe Michaels ヶ月 前

    "Unauthorized immigrant." Love Vox's use of these euphemisms. THEY ARE *ILLEGAL* ALIENS. No getting around that -- no matter WHAT term you use.

  • Becca Wilkerson
    Becca Wilkerson ヶ月 前

    City and county police should work with the federal officers to remove any and all illegal immigrants from our country. Cooperation is key.

  • Michael Gray
    Michael Gray ヶ月 前

    Immigrants or illegals

  • Michael Gray
    Michael Gray ヶ月 前

    Where can I go black man

  • Jujus Ramirez
    Jujus Ramirez ヶ月 前

    Why are channels like vox still here?

  • Chaas Haas
    Chaas Haas ヶ月 前

    Why does everyone want to live in countries created by white people

  • John Featherstone
    John Featherstone ヶ月 前

    It's really just that people employed on the state or municipality's dime have no obligation to enforce federal law. The only instances where they do is where it proves convenient or politically expedient for their bosses to tell them to. E.g. fair housing laws where the city could be reasonably implicated in federal court cases for signing off on developments in breach of the law.
    In this case, if the federal government wants to enforce its immigration policy, it needs to pay people to do it. It can't expect city officials to go against the will of the people that voted them into office and do it for them.

  • The Canada First Party

    sanctuary city is a nice wording for ethnic ghetto

  • zilamat megazoid
    zilamat megazoid ヶ月 前

    If you are an illegal immigrant it is illegal to be in the country you illegally immigrated to...it s common sense people

  • llaevigrof
    llaevigrof ヶ月 前

    Within seconds this video is bashing the right... What a joke. I know shootings, robberies, rapes and gang activity have increased massively in a 'Sanctuary' state. Living as parasites off the people...governments own nothing, so it is being taken from people. You can't go into any other country like they are in America. So many lies.

  • Michael Cookston
    Michael Cookston ヶ月 前

    This video is totally bs and federal law trump state law anyways.

  • Rick Larsen
    Rick Larsen ヶ月 前

    Wow, lefties only quote the Tenth Amendment when it suits them. I actually agree with them on this one but also they really need to apply #10 to the plethora of things lefties want the federal government to do as well. I am also for ending federal funding in general and keeping the money in the states it came from. Trump signing that executive order is what authoritarianism looks like folks. Using the Tenth Amendment and keeping that money in the states is how you prevent authoritarianism.

  • gyokatracho
    gyokatracho ヶ月 前

    Fake news this channel should be canceled by biased and fake news

  • Miguel Oliveira
    Miguel Oliveira ヶ月 前

    Basically we want to let them free and deny the request, so "criminals" or law-breaker illegal immigrants can report on other criminals? Here's the thing right, if people start to do these requests, and the illegal immigrant community starts to get robbed more, they'll just move out. They'll either go back, or they'll go somewhere else and get caught. If they're here legally there's no issue with the police, but since they're here illegally they put themselves between a rock and a hard place themselves.

  • Warren Mitchum
    Warren Mitchum ヶ月 前

    So don't work with government officials and that's somehow legal.

  • B Moe
    B Moe ヶ月 前

    So you drop illegal off of immigrants, wonder why?

  • Dovahgatr
    Dovahgatr ヶ月 前

    Wonder how many of these subscribers are actually robots :P

  • RoyalGaming
    RoyalGaming ヶ月 前

    Amazing, two sanctuary cities also have some of the highest crime rates over most of the US

  • Tanish Jain
    Tanish Jain ヶ月 前 +1

    I pity the police
    Minecraft animation was great

  • Karecmeister
    Karecmeister ヶ月 前

    "Human sacrifices"? REALLY...?

  • Nick Walsh
    Nick Walsh ヶ月 前 +1

    Failure to comply and Cooperate with Federal Law Enforcement is a federal crime. Simple as that.

    • Nick Walsh
      Nick Walsh ヶ月 前 +1

      If you break the law, I have no sympathy for you. Illegal Immigration is breaking the law.

  • dhobstone
    dhobstone ヶ月 前

    U Visa is an example that helps illegal immigrants who are victims or suspects in violence such as human trafficking, homicides, or domestic violence. I’m sure there are ways around scaring illegal immigrants from speaking out, but how would they know about these things without actually having knowledge about these kinds of policies?

  • PrettyBoiBozo
    PrettyBoiBozo ヶ月 前

    Illegal immigrants are illegal and for that reason they should be deported. I’m Mexican and even I understand this

  • logic first
    logic first ヶ月 前

    California shocking.

  • Kevan Valentine-platt

    Vox like breaking laws

  • Robert Greenberg
    Robert Greenberg ヶ月 前

    Did you hear that? Immigrants will be afraid to call the police because they will be deported. Maybe it should say illegal immigrants should be afraid. Once again lets blur the lines. I also love it when This is a good article. Follow the link for more information. Page move-protected
    Rahm Emanuel said Chicago id safe.

  • Bennnnny1987
    Bennnnny1987 ヶ月 前

    Sanctuary city = hotspot for illegals and crime.

  • Jeff Gazetti
    Jeff Gazetti ヶ月 前

    If the illegals aren’t here then they can’t get robbed. It is their presence here that is the root cause of criminals being enabled.

  • monty fresh
    monty fresh ヶ月 前

    do not trust Vox. some stuff is entertaining, a lot is fake news and propaganda

  • Hippy Ken
    Hippy Ken ヶ月 前

    Chattanooga tn sucks.... it's a sanctuary City

  • Cecelia Passarella
    Cecelia Passarella ヶ月 前

    End Santuary Cities

  • Austin Lambeth
    Austin Lambeth ヶ月 前

    if you deport all the illegal immigrants then you dont have to deal with them not cooperating

  • The ice mask gang
    The ice mask gang ヶ月 前

    Gotta Deport em all

  • ajones363
    ajones363 ヶ月 前

    That guy from LA looks like the chief of police in Blue Bloods.

  • The King of cats
    The King of cats ヶ月 前

    Who thinks ice is a cool name

  • Martin
    Martin ヶ月 前

    “When a foreigner resides among you in your land, do not mistreat them. *_The foreigner residing among you must be treated as your native-born_* . Love them as yourself, for you were foreigners in Egypt. I am the Lord your God." -Leviticus 19: 33-34
    The Word of the Lord

  • William C
    William C ヶ月 前

    Well, they shouldn’t be in the country anyways.

  • GatoKa
    GatoKa ヶ月 前

    This was actually very informative. However, immigrants don’t want to interact with the police whether victims of crimes or not. I grew up in an immigrant community, so I know firsthand as the son of legal immigrants.

  • Ben Morrow
    Ben Morrow ヶ月 前

    Deport

  • Adam Beer AKA Sapphire

    What I don't get is, you said it stops them from doing their job when they report them to ICE. But if they dont then they aren't doing their job. I feel for these people, I really do. But you can't just ignore that someone us breaking the law in case other people that are breaking the law are afraid of getting caught. Take this for example: a murderer gets pulled over for speeding. Same situation. This time, through fingerprints, they find out he's a murderer. You wouldn't expect them to go "hmmm... well I COULD arrest this guy. But then again, if OTHER murderers hear about it, they won't call the police if something happens". It's ridiculous. And we aren't talking about asylum seekers or legal immigrants. We're talking about ILLEGAL immigrants. By letting this happen, it's kinda like a massive middle finger to the people that have struggled for years and years to get visas to get into the country and live there. Not to mention the fact that it makes other illegal immigrants think it's ok to do that. And it's not ok. It's illegal for a reason. And I know that these are people too, but you can emigrate legally. If you can't appreciate the laws of the country you want to move to, then you shouldn't be there. And if it is urgent and you can't get the visa. Say you're living in a country in the middle of war and you need to move away, for your family's sake. I get it. It's awful. But you can be granted asylum. And if not, then clearly there's a reason. Whether it be because this person is deemed a danger, or because there are simply other people that need it more urgently, there will be a reason. So to move there anyway because you can't do it the legit way is just wrong. I can't always afford the basics to live off of. But I don't steal from the local supermarket. I get by the legal way. That's why these laws are being passed. If ICE have requested something and you ignore it, then damn well you should get a fine or less funding. I'm sorry if you don't agree but that's just how I feel. And I think I presented my argument coherently enough for people reading it to understand what I'm trying to say

  • Creature _73L
    Creature _73L ヶ月 前

    You claim in your video that the word gets out to the immigrant community that if you talk with police you’ll get deported. Where is this happening that US citizens are getting deported because they immigrated to the US? Oh wait.... you conveniently left out that they’re illegally in this country to begin with.

  • Phil Bob
    Phil Bob ヶ月 前

    Vox is fake news. Mexico sucks, who the hell wants to live there, and why the he’ll would you want it here?

  • De León
    De León 2 ヶ月 前

    The solution is simple, LEGAL inmigration

  • Derek Hunter
    Derek Hunter 2 ヶ月 前

    So one conclusion to draw here is that some crime is okay. The crime of illegally crossing the border and taking up illegal residence in the USA is now acceptable. What other drimes are okay? If we don't enforce some laws how can we justify enforcing others?

  • J4K3 Krebs
    J4K3 Krebs 2 ヶ月 前

    Got dang liberals ruinin our cantree!

  • Elvis Johnson
    Elvis Johnson 2 ヶ月 前

    One year later and we still have our Sanctuary cities! Where's Jeff Sessions And Pres Trump?

  • James Baxter
    James Baxter 2 ヶ月 前

    If you don't pay taxes why would you get coverage of any service

  • Jason Krone
    Jason Krone 2 ヶ月 前

    Not surprised because Vox received funding from the Chinese government

  • DeltaFlare987
    DeltaFlare987 2 ヶ月 前

    Nope. For cops that's a win win situation. They get to deport all the illegals here in this country try. Bye bye

  • Patrick Bunney
    Patrick Bunney 2 ヶ月 前

    1:10, I'm sure that you could not possibly have said 'he' in place of 'they' or 'he or she'.
    Bigots.

  • Adam Jenkins
    Adam Jenkins 2 ヶ月 前

    Republicans have no moral conscience. Religious but no love for their fellow man? Don't they read the holy book??? Its going downhill

  • S Sullivan
    S Sullivan 2 ヶ月 前 +1

    High crime rates are driven by poverty. Solution: open the borders to impoverished, uneducated peoples of the 3rd world. Also let them drive down the price of labor so the more unfortunate of this country have a harder time trying to compete for jobs. Keep it up liberals. This is one of the main reasons Trump won.

    • Afi James
      Afi James ヶ月 前

      And it could happen again in 2020.

  • furstenfeldbruck
    furstenfeldbruck 2 ヶ月 前

    We need Mexicans to do our jobs

  • Ichijo Festival
    Ichijo Festival 2 ヶ月 前

    Really not surprised there are so many Cons here who clearly didn't watch the video.

  • John Doe
    John Doe 2 ヶ月 前 +2

    I can’t believe how many people miss the point.
    Is being an illegal immigrant against the law? Yes.
    Does that mean all law enforcement are obligated to enforce it? No. Federalism means that different levels of government have different responsibilities. Some overlap, some don’t. If you want federal law to overrule all local law, might I suggest a Unitary State, where local regions have little to no say in how they are governed?

  • henk detank
    henk detank 2 ヶ月 前

    don't be illegal? i don't get the big problem here?

    • henk detank
      henk detank 2 ヶ月 前

      Ichijo Festival if it was easy people would abuse it like they are trying to do now by being illegal

    • Ichijo Festival
      Ichijo Festival 2 ヶ月 前

      I would suggest you look into how an immigrant becomes "legal." If it were that easy, this wouldn't be a problem.

  • Nunu Rats
    Nunu Rats 2 ヶ月 前

    Undocumented immigrants are already afraid of contacting police due to already being criminals from trespassing in a different country.

    • Ichijo Festival
      Ichijo Festival 2 ヶ月 前

      The police don't typically interrogate victims, or ask for their ID, or birth certificates. But putting that aside, you missed the part where they could also be witnesses. Even if they aren't directly involved in a case, they can still assist the police in resolving a case. In a Sanctuary City, they're less likely to disappear when the police need them.

  • U Cray-Cray
    U Cray-Cray 2 ヶ月 前

    There is a huge difference between an illegal immigrant who is arrested after committing a crime, and an illegal immigrant who is a victim of a crime.
    Yes, both technically should be deported but the criminals are the only ones who are being DEPORTED. if they can’t seem to follow OUR rules, then they are no longer welcome to stay.

  • Chris Butler
    Chris Butler 2 ヶ月 前 +1

    Yeah, yeah, yeah. More libtard dribble. It is really about votes and cheap labor. Have worked construction for years and have seen it first hand. Exp. Framing crew is made up entirely of illegals I am assuming they are illegal because when a cop is around they disappear until he is gone and none can speak english and then when payday comes the white owner shows up in his decked out pickup truck with envelopes full of cash. The left claims US citizens don't want these jobs so the illegals are needed to do them. The truth is that legal folks won't work these jobs because they can't make a living doing them. The illegals pay no taxes what so ever the owner of the business gets rich and any business that does not use them can't compete and are run out of business. I've seen it and know it to be true. The key is to go after the business owners that do this. Start arresting the owners and this crap would stop.

  • eka nanda
    eka nanda 2 ヶ月 前

    Why do many people hate illegal immigrants? As long as they don't do harmful things, immigration is the right of all people.

    • Afi James
      Afi James 2 ヶ月 前

      wrong, illegal immigration is killing America and wrecking American sovereignty.

  • Matthew Wardle
    Matthew Wardle 2 ヶ月 前

    So whats the solution vox?

  • Joe Davola
    Joe Davola 2 ヶ月 前

    VOX is a liberal rag. I wouldn't even use it to wipe oil off my hands while changing my oil. I love the narrator too. Can anyone say GUILTY WHITE?

  • rayzur9
    rayzur9 2 ヶ月 前

    VOX SUCKS. OUT OF TOUCH WITH REALITY.