How sanctuary cities actually work

共有
埋め込みコード
  • に公開 2017/04/25
  • President Trump says he wants to strip funding from so-called "sanctuary cities," but what exactly do these cities do?
    Subscribe to our channel! goo.gl/0bsAjO
    The map at 4:26 comes from the Immigrant Legal Resource Center (www.ilrc.org/local-enforcement-map)
    Cities and counties that limit their cooperation with federal immigration agents are sometimes called "sanctuaries," but the word doesn't actually have any legal meaning. However, because the constitution prohibits the federal government from making states enforce its laws, cities, counties, and other local jurisdictions have lots of freedom to ignore, or comply with, requests from federal agencies like ICE to detain undocumented immigrants for deportation.
    Vox.com is a news website that helps you cut through the noise and understand what's really driving the events in the headlines. Check out www.vox.com to get up to speed on everything from Kurdistan to the Kim Kardashian app.
    Check out our full video catalog: goo.gl/IZONyE
    Follow Vox on Twitter: goo.gl/XFrZ5H
    Or on Facebook: goo.gl/U2g06o

コメント数 • 6 204

  • Trippy's Chill Spot

    Yeah Sanctuariy Cities work.... They work to show us how they fail.

  • EjamGaming MC
    EjamGaming MC 3 日 前

    Except most of these illegals are being detained bc of an unpaid speeding ticket

  • Ethan Allen
    Ethan Allen 4 日 前

    Vox....open your eyes....sanctuary cities are cancer.

  • Austin Barrick
    Austin Barrick 5 日 前

    Leftism is an infectious disease you people are being hood winked

  • cattleNhay
    cattleNhay 9 日 前

    You make it sound like American costumed criminals (cops) can actually decide anything for themselves... Of course not: they just follow orders from the corporations that hired them.

  • ShadowAR TV
    ShadowAR TV 12 日 前

    Thanks needed to know this 👋😁

  • Дмитрий
    Дмитрий 14 日 前

    I don’t live in USA and I just wanna know, is there a single good thing Trump did? A single one? Please, if it’s there, tell me it seems to have gone over my head.

  • James W.
    James W. 14 日 前

    Invasion USA.

  • Dana Evans
    Dana Evans 15 日 前

    Unauthorized immigrants shouldn't put themselves in a position to be fingerprinted by police. Don't break the law. If you break the law then.......... maybe you should go home. It's those that do not break laws that I feel for.

  • Poison Kiss
    Poison Kiss 19 日 前

    So basically if you are okay with illegal immigration, you ain't a snitch. If you are against illegal immigration, you're a snitch.
    Mind ya business.

  • SilencedFiend
    SilencedFiend 19 日 前

    Still breaking the law

  • noah
    noah 21 日 前

    Sanctuary cities are illegal. Only states can do that. And even then its wrong. Becuz the illegals dint stay in those states

  • Captain Keyes
    Captain Keyes 22 日 前

    Love how there is no data for the whole state of WV when bring up the map

  • NMguy70
    NMguy70 24 日 前

    Charlie Beck for President

  • Donald Gorth
    Donald Gorth 24 日 前 +1

    What's really funny is the illegals in these cities are killing the idiots that voted for this...The illegals in these cities have degraded these cities so much that people are moving out ....GOOD JOB IDIOTS...

    • Mr_Cynical
      Mr_Cynical 18 日 前

      Oh yeah. New York and Chicago are such hellholes JUST because of illegal immigrants. 1. Illegal immigrants commit a fraction of all murders (less that their wedge of the population) 2. No on eis flocking out of sanctuary cities. That's just an ignorant claim

  • Lauraren101
    Lauraren101 24 日 前 +2

    This channel makes me 2% more woke every video I watch

  • MUD BUKET
    MUD BUKET 25 日 前

    Doha debates sounds dumb af

  • varun kv
    varun kv 25 日 前

    Where do they deport if they are undocumented immigrants?

  • The RightStuff
    The RightStuff 26 日 前

    1/8th of the people in LA are illegal aliens, probably a higher percentage of those living in apartments; so if you deport illegal aliens in LA, apartments will finally be affordable! If 5-10% of apartments became vacant, it would not be a discount of 30-50%+. Rents fell from $800 to $400 in my city from the 2008 economic downturn, but now they start at $1200 (most jobs pay that much, or less if they won't give you many hours.)

  • S D
    S D 26 日 前 +1

    This is SO SIMPLE u say people calling police to report someone can’t be arrested. But if you get arrested than you can be deported. For example If an illegal calls the cops on a robber, the illegal immigrant who called wont be reported, but the robber can be reported and deported
    We have that same law for drug overdoses. You can’t be arrested for drugs, if ur calling to save someone’s life if there overdosing. Sanctuary cities are dumb. They protect murderers. Plenty of illegals want illegal criminals in there neighborhood deported. A lot of them left there country to get away from criminals

  • Rodolfo Ayala
    Rodolfo Ayala 28 日 前

    Angry bird 🐦.😠 Fox’s channels.

  • brettdumain
    brettdumain 28 日 前

    You know what would solve this problem? A Big, Beautiful Wall, followed by mass deportation. No need to worry about "immigration status" if you arent here...

  • Prah Space
    Prah Space 29 日 前

    Trump is the Hitler of 21st Century although his son in Law is Jew

  • Bob Singh
    Bob Singh ヶ月 前

    What? So what you're saying is illegal immigrants have the same rights as legal citizens?

    • Дмитрий
      Дмитрий 14 日 前

      They re saying humans have the same rights as, well, humans, I guess.

  • oil9vinergar
    oil9vinergar ヶ月 前

    the slickwillys sent in the special forces when Miami politicians refused to help with the deportation of that Cuban kid... the politicians=tapeworms of sanctuary cities are doing the same. President Trump, as the chief magistrate of the United States must send in the special forces, clean out those sanctuary cities, and arrest all politicians=tapeworms, sycophantic propagandists, and shysters not helping with enforcement of US laws for aiding and abating in criminal activities.... what's good for the goose is good for the gander, after all.

  • DONGOE
    DONGOE ヶ月 前

    What would happen to me if I assaulted/murdered an illegal alien in a sanctuary city?

  • Matthew Galter
    Matthew Galter ヶ月 前

    I love how the cop is white and the illegals are, of course, brown hahahaaaa

  • Matthew Galter
    Matthew Galter ヶ月 前

    I live in Chicago... It ain't safe w murder rates higher than a war zone. Forgot that part too, did we now, VOX? How convenient

  • Matthew Galter
    Matthew Galter ヶ月 前

    This is propaganda, for all u gay people at VOX U sure don't tell people how gay bashing is such a huge problem in sanctuary cites

  • bigbrain457
    bigbrain457 ヶ月 前

    I don't get how you allow people who are illegal to obtain the same service as tax payers.

  • Duston McCreary
    Duston McCreary ヶ月 前

    By breathing federal laws, by protecting illegal violent criminals, by giving illegals social benefits, and giving illegals local voting rights. California has cities filing for bankruptcy left and right. How’s it working so far?

  • Britney Dockery
    Britney Dockery ヶ月 前

    ‘It hard to do their job without trust’. Black people don’t trust the cops and police do their job brutality well.

  • Mr Kurtz
    Mr Kurtz ヶ月 前

    Why the heck are we talking about retainer requests? Why are they not calling ICE directly and saying “Come pick this guy up.”???
    And LA has 500,000 illegal immigrants?!?! Why are they not rounding them all up and deporting them? Why are they not doing things that cause these people to write home and say “Don’t sneak over the border and come to LA. They will get you. Just stay home and do your best down there. “
    Why is this not happening?

  • Michelle Miller
    Michelle Miller ヶ月 前

    This is so sickening just makes me sick I won’t go to jail I. I kill people yew haw lawless America

  • D. MARTIN
    D. MARTIN ヶ月 前

    Deport. Build a wall. American's first not after foreigners. Problem solved. Wtf.

  • J Law
    J Law ヶ月 前

    Ofcourse vox knows better than anyone else ..

  • Sheep De sheep
    Sheep De sheep ヶ月 前

    Yeet

  • TheGrump101
    TheGrump101 ヶ月 前

    This video claims to break it down to be so simple. It is not. The fact is that local governments have a duty to follow laws. These cities are now choosing not to at the helm of losing funds.

  • Richard
    Richard ヶ月 前

    "One of the nation's most marginalized groups." Time to look up what "nation" means...

  • Steve BigEve
    Steve BigEve ヶ月 前

    That argument of immigrants being soft targets for deportation doesn't make sense. If you only get deported after you COMMIT A CRIME AND GO TO JAIL WHERE YOU GET FINGERPRINTED, why would they be afraid to call the cops if they're a victim? Victims get arrested, transported, and fingerprinted these days?
    Sidenote, to fit their narrative they use a "speeding ticket warrant" as an example. Unpaid speeding tickets aren't a criminal offense (except in NV). People don't get arrested for unpaid speeding ticket fines. Unless of course it's criminal speeding.

  • Thomas M
    Thomas M ヶ月 前

    This is how libtards play coy and put illegals and legal immigrants in the same category by calling them all immigrant. They know this is the only way to get future voters to replace the ones leaving the democratic plantation. Technically an immigrant is someone who's come to some place legally, if not then you're just a law breaker

  • I3LINK
    I3LINK ヶ月 前

    Even if it does encourage illegal immigrants to report crimes, it's still better in the long run to ensure the country is full of people who pay their taxes and follow the law. Either get your green card or seek asylum, and if you can't seek asylum, chances are your country is safe enough to live in. People who aren't qualified to get a green card are clearly not gonna be a great benefit to the economy.

  • Ryan Walker
    Ryan Walker ヶ月 前

    Liberal propaganda bull crap

  • cameron mccarthy
    cameron mccarthy ヶ月 前

    Nonsense

  • Dennis Murphy
    Dennis Murphy ヶ月 前

    They don't. True story... You are fake news!

  • grafvonstauffenburg
    grafvonstauffenburg ヶ月 前

    The "detainers" must be sanctioned; otherwise, more YOUNG WOMEN will be murdered by ILLEGALS, e.g., Kate Steinle and the young woman in Iowa......as well as hundreds of others.... ILLEGAL ALIEN cooperation is one of those myths those who call themselves "leftist" have INVENTED to thwart rational policy.....in the same vein as the silly shiboleth, "Nation of Immigrants," as the governing axiom of in-migration policy for the U.S. & the West.....!
    Let the Third World stay where it is and 'fight it out'--at the very least, it will HELP staunch their rampant OVERPOPULATION..!!

  • spitchill
    spitchill ヶ月 前

    How they work?!
    Crime, drug use and taxes go up.
    Productivity and property values go down.
    Pretty simple.

  • Ray Milligan
    Ray Milligan ヶ月 前

    Vox is Joke!

  • Kendall Fort
    Kendall Fort ヶ月 前

    News should be Subjective, not objective. Keep reporting, just reign in the personal opinions

  • richard thayer
    richard thayer ヶ月 前

    STOP PROTECTING MEXICAN METH DEALERS ... STOP YOUR LIES LIBERAL MEDIA!

  • jim h
    jim h ヶ月 前

    Sanctuary cities..
    I commend you for standing up for your believes...
    But when you don't support and obey federal laws...
    You shouldn't get any federal money..
    And should be held responcable for any crimes those you protect commit

  • PatheticTV
    PatheticTV ヶ月 前

    someone tell me which scientist said that, based on THEIR OWN research, fingerprints are unique. go on, i'll wait.

  • Spike Spiegel
    Spike Spiegel ヶ月 前

    more block people stories please

  • Ken Richard
    Ken Richard ヶ月 前

    Bull crap!
    It should tell illegal immigrants that they should not commit crime or they may be deported!
    It is a stretch to argue that mere interaction with the police will result in deportation!!!

  • Last Lime
    Last Lime ヶ月 前

    How they don't work....

  • My Krazy life
    My Krazy life ヶ月 前

    How about this if an immigrant is a victim of a crime or sees a crime they are guaranteed to not be harassed by their immigration status

  • no name
    no name ヶ月 前

    Why do sanctuary cities exist at all. Weak spineless repubs and commie-socialist dems!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Tom Crenshaw
    Tom Crenshaw ヶ月 前

    Shut it down no more

  • Samuel Torres
    Samuel Torres ヶ月 前

    "You are safe in Chicago"
    Me: weird flex but ok

  • Peter McM
    Peter McM ヶ月 前 +2

    Why does vox have such a problem with the right wing

    • Дмитрий
      Дмитрий 14 日 前

      Peter McM yeah, why do sane humans have a problem with nazis? No clue, no clue.

  • Surfer Bob
    Surfer Bob ヶ月 前

    If I lived in a sanctuary city I’d move ASAP. A city that goes out of its way to house and protect illegal felons? Seriously? Insanity. Look at Oakland, that violent third world Hell hole deserves the reputation it has. Peace. ✌️

  • The Adventure of Jesus & Einstein

    This sound like Vox is trying to sell this!! Lol 😂

  • TheTechRepublic
    TheTechRepublic 2 ヶ月 前

    I am not from Alaska nor Hawaii but a 4:29. You didn’t include Alaska nor Hawaii.

  • Alejandra Orellana
    Alejandra Orellana 2 ヶ月 前

    It all comes down to "You don't bite the hand that feeds you"

  • John Wayne
    John Wayne 2 ヶ月 前

    Have you seen San Francisco I wouldn’t want to there now a days

  • Derek Smith
    Derek Smith 2 ヶ月 前 +1

    Watch out illegal immigrants you are not safe anywhere in the USA Trump is going to see today

  • PlayingMantis999
    PlayingMantis999 2 ヶ月 前

    they shouldnt live in the us in the first place if there illegal so i dont rlly care what happens to them

  • Sean Brown
    Sean Brown 2 ヶ月 前

    =You know why conservatives continue to watch Vox, Vice, anything that openly liberal? Because they're true believers. If you condemn letting people into our nation, finding a way for them to contribute, and growing as a whole than you're un-american.

  • Frank L
    Frank L 2 ヶ月 前

    If you rob a bank in a Sanctuary City, is it illegal or is it just an Undocumented Withdrawal?

  • Michael Suk
    Michael Suk 2 ヶ月 前

    I'll tell you how they work. Take a good look at St. Cloud, MN. It used to be a great suburb of the Twin Cities, and now it's a sh*thole. If you're female, don't go to St. Cloud State University. You have a good chance of being sexually assaulted by an immigrant.

  • Eric Cholico
    Eric Cholico 2 ヶ月 前

    4:41 The way Trump opened the pen though lol

  • Robloxeli
    Robloxeli 2 ヶ月 前

    This is showing all of Fox news ... Not CNN ... what does that tell me? FAKE NEWS! The left want to cover it all up like it's not a big deal... why are so many people moving out of California to get away from all the mess.... It's sick!

  • XDARKFUTUREX
    XDARKFUTUREX 2 ヶ月 前

    So for an alien already living in the states, what would that person need to do to gain citizenship?

  • Jeff lin
    Jeff lin 2 ヶ月 前

    The FBI is in this.

  • Raphael
    Raphael 2 ヶ月 前

    The assumption that Hispanic individuals are scared to report a crime due to deportation is incorrect.
    Also, educating the Hispanic community about deporting only the trouble makers will go a long way.

  • Name: Luke
    Name: Luke 2 ヶ月 前

    So, maybe the world is a simulation created by AI in the future who could time travel therefore we are living in the game created by them in the future.

  • FTM _
    FTM _ 2 ヶ月 前

    Seattle should have run the ball.

  • Tony Wu
    Tony Wu 2 ヶ月 前

    *Triggered liberals incoming*

  • Steve Witt
    Steve Witt 2 ヶ月 前

    follow the law stupid

  • Sunny Smiles
    Sunny Smiles 3 ヶ月 前

    If the sanctuary cities are that worried about the illegal immigrants safety that they won’t cooperate w detainers, that means they could care less about legal citizen safety. let them deal with their city problems on their own. These democratic run cities are much more worried about if the illegals are safe from criminals versus if citizens are safe from illegals Because many times the criminals are illegals!!!! They have continually put the needs of illegals ahead of legal citizens because they have turned this identity politics into a way to get continual voter support just to stay in power of state and city government. They waste their own taxpayer dollars due to the high welfare entitlements and bloated city pension plans, over tax their working citizens, run off businesses, then they want to be bailed out by the federal Government. TOO BAD!!!! STOP BAILING OUT SANCTUARY CITIES!!!! They need consequences to their actions!!!!!

  • Liam Young
    Liam Young 3 ヶ月 前

    Let's be honest it's not going to be "speeding"

  • Bennie Straughan
    Bennie Straughan 3 ヶ月 前

    You are safe in Houston, Texas. We have an estimated 20,000 gang members here. I heard a man on You Tube say that it is a sign of a sick society, that chooses to enforce one set of laws, and then chooses not to enforce
    another set of laws. Truer words were never spoken.

  • Adam B.
    Adam B. 3 ヶ月 前

    How many are we going to allow from there to come here before here becomes there?

  • Adam B.
    Adam B. 3 ヶ月 前

    I'm an American citizen, I wonder if police would ignore a request from the federal government to hold me in jail another 2 days? Something tells me I shouldn't hold my breath.

  • Jacob Bowl
    Jacob Bowl 3 ヶ月 前

    Ok so let’s not deport drug dealers or immigrants at meth labs

  • John Calaway
    John Calaway 3 ヶ月 前

    This is a one sided atgument. How about this. First they are here illegally which is a crime to begin with. This technically makes all illegal immigrants criminals. Next if we arrest and deport them then there would be less crime. We would solve both issues because there would be no crime to report.
    What about the forging of documents such as Social Security cards or Alien Registration cards. Isn't that a crime. Then we have this scenario if the crime is serious enough then they flee to Mexico or whatever country they came from only to reappear under another alias or name.

  • Z AG
    Z AG 3 ヶ月 前

    Also everyone is male.

  • Z AG
    Z AG 3 ヶ月 前

    How come all the police are white and the immigrants are all people of color?

  • RocknRollDina
    RocknRollDina 3 ヶ月 前

    IF they're illegal, deport them, simple DUH.

  • Crystal Evans
    Crystal Evans 3 ヶ月 前

    I believe Chicago is one of the worst cities as far as crime.

  • SFYNXCI
    SFYNXCI 3 ヶ月 前

    I would not ruin an undocumented immigrants life journey over an unpaid speeding ticket.

  • Daily Red Pill
    Daily Red Pill 3 ヶ月 前

    Corporations and Businesses need to be fined $$$ heavily for hiring illegals They are part of the problem.
    Human trafficking and Child Smuggling earns profits of roughly $150 billion a year for traffickers.
    $99 billion from commercial sexual exploitation
    $34 billion in construction, manufacturing, mining and utilities
    $9 billion in agriculture, including forestry and fishing
    $8 billion dollars is saved annually by private households that employ domestic workers under conditions of forced labor.
    A Global Display Of Human Trafficking Incidents And News
    human.globalincidentmap.com/

  • CounterCraftAndy
    CounterCraftAndy 3 ヶ月 前

    The worst part of this video is the comment section

  • Jakob Silvert
    Jakob Silvert 3 ヶ月 前

    Grossly misrepresented the meaning of the 10th amendment. The 10th absolutely does not "prohibit state governments from having to enforce federal law". It gives the states power beyond congresses enumerated powers.

  • B. M.
    B. M. 3 ヶ月 前 +2

    The issues are very American:
    - If Federal laws supercedes state laws and local town laws, then follow and enforce them; that includes immigration and tourism laws.

    • NO MA'AM
      NO MA'AM 2 ヶ月 前 +1

      B. M. I would think a real American would know what the bill of rights says, particularly the 10th amendment.

  • Melissa Duran
    Melissa Duran 3 ヶ月 前 +2

    An illegal can kill Kate Steinle and be only found guilty of possession of a gun. Yay!

  • Dont Worryabootit
    Dont Worryabootit 3 ヶ月 前

    exactly santuary cities are corrupt and harbouring criminals.

  • Ray Ross
    Ray Ross 3 ヶ月 前

    It's real simple. If everyone was a citizen, then there's no worry about being deported. Once the people who aren't supposed to be here are gone, people won't be afraid to call the police.

  • Yeah Sev
    Yeah Sev 3 ヶ月 前

    Annoying voice