How sanctuary cities actually work

共有
埋め込みコード
  • に公開 2017/04/25
  • President Trump says he wants to strip funding from so-called "sanctuary cities," but what exactly do these cities do?
    Subscribe to our channel! goo.gl/0bsAjO
    The map at 4:26 comes from the Immigrant Legal Resource Center (www.ilrc.org/local-enforcement-map)
    Cities and counties that limit their cooperation with federal immigration agents are sometimes called "sanctuaries," but the word doesn't actually have any legal meaning. However, because the constitution prohibits the federal government from making states enforce its laws, cities, counties, and other local jurisdictions have lots of freedom to ignore, or comply with, requests from federal agencies like ICE to detain undocumented immigrants for deportation.
    Vox.com is a news website that helps you cut through the noise and understand what's really driving the events in the headlines. Check out www.vox.com to get up to speed on everything from Kurdistan to the Kim Kardashian app.
    Check out our full video catalog: goo.gl/IZONyE
    Follow Vox on Twitter: goo.gl/XFrZ5H
    Or on Facebook: goo.gl/U2g06o

コメント数 • 5 822

  • Winnie Levine
    Winnie Levine 日 前

    POTUS TRUMP OFFERED TO SEND THE ILLEGALS BY THE BUSLOADS TO SANCTUARY STATES AND CITIES BUT THEY REFUSED SAYING IT WAS INHUMANE WELL YOU WANTED THEM POTUS TRUMP SHOULD SEND THEM ANYWAY..THEN CUT THEIR FED FUNDING

  • paul castle
    paul castle 2 日 前

    A marginalised group ? Isn't that typical Left wing nonsense ?

  • Strange Sightings
    Strange Sightings 2 日 前

    Deport all illegals if they want to be citizens let them do it the right way, heck a person can't even go to China you have to write a letter to the government of China to visit. And they can still deny it.

  • Chuckles
    Chuckles 2 日 前

    So rule of law and chain of command does not apply in US?

  • Ralph Morales
    Ralph Morales 3 日 前

    This is what happens when you ignore a problem for political reasons, almost always at the end you get trapped in a lose-lose situation either financially or morally.

  • Drahcir Senryb
    Drahcir Senryb 3 日 前

    If the jail holds them and ICE shows up, the illegal immigrant who committed a criminal act just has to claim Asylum, then there's nothing ice can do.

  • Bobbyray Smith
    Bobbyray Smith 3 日 前 +1

    Go to that HOOD in Chicago illegal immigrants and say the "N"WORD ha ha you would wish you would of never came to USA 😂😂🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸

  • Bob Alvarez
    Bob Alvarez 4 日 前 +1

    I’m I missing the larger issue? Aren’t they breaking our laws being here?????

  • Jack Meoff
    Jack Meoff 4 日 前

    If you entered this country illegally it’s a crime and you should be sent back. If you came here legally and committed a crime while waiting for your citizenship you should be sent back.

  • _manifest
    _manifest 5 日 前

    Deport them all anyways. They don’t deserve protection.

  • Jarl Mos
    Jarl Mos 6 日 前

    Funny, I was subscribed to this channel, I don't remember subscribing....hmmm

  • jibmoney
    jibmoney 6 日 前

    Deport them all, build that wall.

  • fast 417
    fast 417 7 日 前

    if an illegal alien doesn't have to pass a background check if arrested, I shouldn't be required to pass one to buy a shotgun

  • fast 417
    fast 417 7 日 前

    if an illegal alien doesn't have to pass a background check if arrested, I shouldn't be required to pass one to buy a shotgun

  • Erik Morales
    Erik Morales 15 日 前 +2

    Im from chicago and i'm just saying... all the people breaking the law are citizens.

  • mr langustinos
    mr langustinos 16 日 前 +1

    Why are there so many Fox News clip

  • Proly Moly
    Proly Moly 17 日 前

    Why can’t illegal immigrants become citizens?

  • Cult Leader
    Cult Leader 18 日 前

    ya they dont work

  • John Robins
    John Robins 18 日 前

    I am so glad I live in Australia which is surrounded by water and a government that stops the boats full illegals coming to our country. I feel for Americans and Europeans who r being swamped by people who don't share their beliefs or values

  • Ryan Darko
    Ryan Darko 18 日 前

    I’m tired of nyc

  • Rein Justme
    Rein Justme 18 日 前

    You are safe in sanctuary cities we don’t have mass shooters and racist...

  • The Pragmatist
    The Pragmatist 19 日 前

    I've never been in US but those cities are also on the "avoid for your safety" list here... Why is this? Is there correlation?

  • MyRandomCommentsXD
    MyRandomCommentsXD 19 日 前 +2

    I'm an immigrant, I came to this country legally. They can't deport me because I am legal.
    2:48 No they are not immigrants. They are illegal aliens

  • Mike Tracy
    Mike Tracy 19 日 前

    You are safe in Chicago??????????????????????

  • Valencia Inc
    Valencia Inc 20 日 前 +4

    Just a tip to for better journalistic integrity, use full quotes not a couple words.

  • Felix DaSilva
    Felix DaSilva 20 日 前

    Go Trump!!!

  • Jarys Satre
    Jarys Satre 22 日 前

    look how racist vox is portraying immigrant families as brown in this video

  • Commander Ultra
    Commander Ultra 23 日 前 +4

    How to fix it: come legally
    :0

    • Presently In The Past
      Presently In The Past 21 日 前

      @Commander Ultra And wait months to years to get murdered?

    • Commander Ultra
      Commander Ultra 21 日 前

      @Presently In The Past So? Come legally.

    • Presently In The Past
      Presently In The Past 21 日 前

      @Commander Ultra These are thousands of people who will be murdered if they don't come to the US. Until you fix other countries, people will still try to escape to the US.

    • Commander Ultra
      Commander Ultra 21 日 前

      @Presently In The Past Are you aware of what your typing? I'm saying we wouldn't need sanctuary cities in the first place if they just came legally.

    • Presently In The Past
      Presently In The Past 21 日 前

      @Commander Ultra What did *you* mean by your original comment. Mine was a response to you implying sanctuary cities are bad.

  • Trent O Donnell
    Trent O Donnell 23 日 前 +1

    Legal......illegal. Why is it so difficult to understand!

    • Andy B
      Andy B 22 日 前

      It's not but it doesn't fit the left's narrative and forces them to have to think for 5 seconds.

  • Johnathan land
    Johnathan land 23 日 前

    Fox xaxa

  • Billie SG
    Billie SG 24 日 前

    I see VOX, so called Journalists, Pinokkio noses growing with their bias reporting

  • ryan bartlette
    ryan bartlette 24 日 前

    That's is a stupid point of view.... the more comfortable a illegal immigrant is the more others will follow making it more of a problem... we have enough homeless people to worrie about even if these people did work it still pushes one legal out of work jobs dont get made out of thin air .... and then the more companies that hire illegal immigrants the more illegal trades go down were houses get built by non documented non certified workers... so on so forth ... its simple to see how bad that would be ...to not enforce people to come here legally and be a part of our social security system or legally documented like the rest of American citizens so they can be held to the laws as the rest of us ......

  • machia0705
    machia0705 24 日 前 +1

    Imbeciles want Sanctuary cities/States.
    It’s a slap in the face to anyone who played by the rules.
    Vote DEMS out. They’re the imbeciles.

  • chris L
    chris L 25 日 前 +1

    goggle Three Teens Charged In Possible MS-13 Related Murder Of 14-Year-Old Girl Killed By Machete,
    when is vox going to report that

  • Ben Dover
    Ben Dover 27 日 前 +1

    Yeah. All this coming from the group who says MS 13 animals are normal, good people. Nothing more than left wing propaganda to destabilize the country. Wake up people!

  • IndraSunrise
    IndraSunrise 28 日 前 +23

    80% of the comment section is about a single quote regarding Chicago.

  • James Murphy
    James Murphy 29 日 前

    One more reason to go after marijuana customers easy to arrest

  • Dominic Nigro
    Dominic Nigro ヶ月 前 +1

    White men are the only thief's in this video

  • Ray Milligan
    Ray Milligan ヶ月 前 +1

    Vox panders to Illegals ! 135 billion dollars spent on Illegals every year for Welfare, google it ! the Center for Immigration Studies, the cost of Welfare by Immigrants and Native households ! the Tax payers pays for people who aren't even Citizens of the United States ! A

  • Goodtree
    Goodtree ヶ月 前 +2

    this video is total propaganda. lol. I live in Tucson AZ, a sanctuary city an hour from the border, and the way they took care of the high crime rates in our city, was by drawing a huge boarder around the heart of the city with the highest concentration of illegals. They then designated this area a separate city altogether, called it "The City of South Tucson" and Voila! The number of crimes in Tucson dropped overnight because the concentration of illegals in the heart of the city, have been handed their own new city. So now all the kidnappings, rapes and murders in The City of South Tucson, don't show up on The City of Tucson statistics even though The City of South Tucson is surrounded by the City of Tucson . This is how we fight illegal immigration in sanctuary cities. As the illegals flood in, we have to be brave enough to stand up and draw a new line on a map, giving the land to the illegals altogether. SMH That's how sanctuary cities work. This video is for people that need to be told what to think by the globalists. Those people always get manipulated. Count me out.

  • Derek Wolford
    Derek Wolford ヶ月 前

    Yeah... I'm just going to thumbs down as real quick.

  • John Fahoum
    John Fahoum ヶ月 前

    is it just me that is annoyed that the cop was having like a seizure

  • Canadian Kid, eh?
    Canadian Kid, eh? ヶ月 前

    So biased lmao.

  • JackofSpades
    JackofSpades ヶ月 前

    Disliked

  • TRUTH HURTS
    TRUTH HURTS ヶ月 前 +1

    Ice shouldn't half to hold them Common Sense should. The moment you receive a request they shouldn't even be requesting when it pops back up saying hold you should hold!🤤

  • B CG
    B CG ヶ月 前

    Do Americans just say "great state of ____" because it rhymes? Like, they say it about all 50, so what do you call a REALLY great state?

  • Andrew Olson
    Andrew Olson ヶ月 前

    JPclips needs a % like, just like pornhub. Vox would be slaughtered

  • GUTO CASTELO GUTO
    GUTO CASTELO GUTO ヶ月 前

    Whe need deport this illegal imigrants from mexico

  • Jackson Schellhorn
    Jackson Schellhorn ヶ月 前

    People that have no respect for our laws deserve the protection of our laws why? That’s the real question.

  • MamalovesherKamadoJoe

    Why do we protect immigrants in our country maybe they will go home.

  • TravisWeb Entertainment

    Way to cherry-pick and take out of context Conservative commentators. Making your place a "sanctuary city" is only making you a target for more illegal immigrants. We need to discourage illegal immigration and encourage people wishing to live here to follow proper immigration procedures.
    BTW, say it with me; "Illegal immigrant" not "unauthorized immigrant" They're here illegally.

  • Javier Baez
    Javier Baez ヶ月 前

    Send them back

  • Jacob Seiberg
    Jacob Seiberg ヶ月 前

    1:01 They got the placement of the star wrong

  • Adam Bratvold
    Adam Bratvold ヶ月 前

    or just deport them all?

  • Laid Back
    Laid Back ヶ月 前

    This makes me wonder ... just who are these bad guys who are obviously super predators among their own people? More illegal immigrants? This is not sound reasoning and the facts appear to be skewed to promote the belief that legal Americans citizens are a threat to illegals. STOP THE INSANITY!

  • Mark Felder
    Mark Felder ヶ月 前

    Here is the reason why there are sanctuary cities.
    jpclips.net/video/waeMkka60po/ビデオ.html

  • Annabeth Chase
    Annabeth Chase ヶ月 前 +2

    I live in a cesspool sanctuary city to be honest. People trash the city and there are (highschool) gangs everywhere and no one does anything.

  • Derrick
    Derrick ヶ月 前

    Then you shouldnt let illegals in the country in the first place.

  • Adam Edward
    Adam Edward ヶ月 前 +2

    Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, The wretched refuse of your teeming shore. Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me, I lift my lamp beside the golden door!

  • aric theodorson
    aric theodorson ヶ月 前 +3

    Interesting that sanctuary cities didnt want illegal aliens when it was suggested that all the people crossing the southern border be sent there. Nobody seems to understand that it is best for all countries to help people where they live.

    • Presently In The Past
      Presently In The Past 21 日 前

      www.businessinsider.com/us-mayors-call-trump-bluff-on-sending-detained-migrants-sanctuary-cities-2019-4

      "The city would be prepared to welcome these immigrants just as we have embraced our immigrant communities for decades." - Philadelphia Mayor Jim Kenney

      They are not hypocrites, despite what Fox News has told you.

  • Victor Yanez
    Victor Yanez ヶ月 前

    Biased much. shut down the border. This stupid commentator forgot to mention that those illegal aliens that get turned back into the streets rape and murder people!

  • GuitarThunder
    GuitarThunder ヶ月 前

    you're safe in Los Angeles, the city that have no respect for American citizens, American flag, borders, federal government and president, a city that only respect homelessness and chaos, welcome to los mexucos.

  • Avery PVZ
    Avery PVZ ヶ月 前 +1

    yet again, they blur the line between legal and illegal immigrant

  • Dylan McCair
    Dylan McCair ヶ月 前

    They keep saying immigrants are scared of getting deported, it’s illegals that are scared, if they’re here illegally and they don’t pay taxes, they shouldn’t have access to these like people who do pay taxes

  • mechaart
    mechaart ヶ月 前 +1

    Well.... Now Demonrats can have illegals squatting near their gated mansions in California.... wonder if they'll open their hearts and doors for them.

  • ramms mutter69
    ramms mutter69 ヶ月 前

    Sanctuary cities basically refuse to cooperate with Federal authorities and don't allow the law to be exercised. These cities will be punished severely for doing this in the near future. They are not off the hook.

  • José Arcadio Buendia

    0:10 "Human sacrifices, rapes, murders" - "Satan worshippers"
    They forgot legalized cannibalism, incest and zoophilia.

  • Matt F
    Matt F ヶ月 前 +25

    1980s: illegal aliens, 1990s: illegal immigrants, 2000s undocumented immigrants, now: just immigrants

  • DD8081
    DD8081 ヶ月 前 +7

    It's amazing how biased this video is.

  • DD8081
    DD8081 ヶ月 前

    liberals are cancerous

  • evman1396
    evman1396 ヶ月 前 +2

    If we didn’t have any ILLEGAL immigrants local cops wouldn’t have to worry about anything now would they?

  • Jonathan Nelson
    Jonathan Nelson ヶ月 前

    Wow, I have never heard such an overly broad interpretation of the 10th amendment. Law enforcement should do just that, enforce the law. Federal, state, local, it doesn't matter.

  • nora kasday
    nora kasday ヶ月 前

    Wait the person calling doesn't go to jail. cops determine if law was broken then detain. This video doesn't make sense.

  • nora kasday
    nora kasday ヶ月 前

    The world is made up of human being let's HAVE the world come here. We have vulnerable children and sick people in the street. I'm Latin American IS CITIZEN and America is FIRST.

  • Wilhelm Grady Ang
    Wilhelm Grady Ang ヶ月 前

    OK ,if sanctuary works. Then put all illegal immigrants there overcrowd them in that place then see what happens. Better yet make an example in California then build a wall around it separate from all parts of America. Give or take 2 years see results.

  • Reviews To The Point

    Congress has to update and change their laws on immigration. But the Democrats don't even want to talk. It's there fault.

  • Butters Scotch
    Butters Scotch ヶ月 前

    Lol human sacrifices???

  • Joseph W.
    Joseph W. ヶ月 前

    This is crazy, to say its anyones fault that illegal immigrants dont cooperate with police. VOX is so liberal. All sanctuary cities are going down in flames. Even Washington D.C. has one of the highest crime rates.

  • brandonshmandon
    brandonshmandon ヶ月 前

    So much misleading info

  • Simon M
    Simon M ヶ月 前

    3:10 I need their votes

  • ely winn
    ely winn ヶ月 前

    There’s a reason there’s a huge homeless problem in every sanctuary city. It’s nice to see the majority of people call this kind of sudo science out. People are done with the radical toxic left.

  • Michael
    Michael ヶ月 前

    amen to trump! maga

  • John and Kay Vest
    John and Kay Vest ヶ月 前

    I am f r o m chicago .the safe and Chicago don't go together . Send more illegals and you can't imagine!

  • MrPubStar
    MrPubStar ヶ月 前 +6

    Vox is cancer. Change my mind.

  • Hulahoney 70
    Hulahoney 70 ヶ月 前

    What if the illegal immigrant kidnapped, raoed or mursered a child? IsDetaining them for 48 hours a bad thing? Catch and release doesnt make these people more helpful to local police. It is the fact that they do not feel safe. Ever heard of dirty cops.

  • Jake E
    Jake E ヶ月 前

    Vox is commie propaganda!!!

  • Craez
    Craez ヶ月 前 +17

    *you are safe in Chicago*
    *LOOKS AT CRIME RATE*
    Ah, I'm not listening to you now.

  • BLAH VIDEO
    BLAH VIDEO ヶ月 前 +6

    Booked and fingerprinted for reporting a crime? 🤔

  • Jerry Rose
    Jerry Rose ヶ月 前

    If your only argument is that the bad guys take advantage of Illegal immigrants who refuse to go to the police for fear of deportation than the answer is simple deport the Illegal immigrants they entered this country through dishonest means, remove illegal immigrants and the bad guys will just find soft targets amongst the legal citizens which they already do.

  • riskbusin3ss
    riskbusin3ss ヶ月 前

    Santa Ana!!

  • GaRdZ
    GaRdZ ヶ月 前

    Number 6 for homicides in the country, stats might disagree you lefty flogbags

  • Jared Beverlin
    Jared Beverlin ヶ月 前 +1

    Lmao they say there arms are open to all till trump offered to send a few million people to this sanctuary cities. Now they say that hes pitting both sides against each other and that they will be less safe.

  • TheMysteriousGamers
    TheMysteriousGamers ヶ月 前 +1

    Wanna solve the problem, don’t let them in, no unjust crime against undocumented citizens because they won’t be here and the police can continue their job

  • Danielle
    Danielle ヶ月 前 +1

    2:52 Why? They are the victims and witnesses not the criminals, why would they be investigated/finger printed? Is that a common practice?

    • Aurora Aleman
      Aurora Aleman ヶ月 前

      They aren't, the video was mentioning that because of word of mouth, if they hear about someone being detained and deported, then they fear that even as much as interacting with an officer will have the same consequence which results in criminals taking advantage of that fear

  • MIKE PHEBUS
    MIKE PHEBUS ヶ月 前

    Just having to explain this mess is pathetic. It's illegal enough said duh.

  • Im Just John
    Im Just John ヶ月 前 +3

    Liberals: “Sanctuary Cities are places of refuge; you’re safe here” 😁
    *Trump says why not let the illegals immigrants go into the sanctuary cities
    Liberals: “ABSOLUTELY UNCONSTITUTIONAL! WHO DO HE THINK HE IS!!?!” 🤬
    Hypocrites at core 🤗

  • Arpit christy
    Arpit christy ヶ月 前

    great content

  • Liam Ramos
    Liam Ramos ヶ月 前

    Whats the problem with immigrating anyways?

  • Jero
    Jero ヶ月 前

    Question: "What does the Bible say about illegal immigration?"
    Answer: Note: We wholeheartedly believe that Christians are called to be compassionate and merciful toward immigrants (Exodus 22:21; Leviticus 19:33-34; Matthew 25:35). We also believe that the United States should have a more compassionate and merciful immigration policy. However, that is not the question at hand. The question at hand concerns illegal immigration-whether it is wrong to violate a nation’s borders and transgress its immigration laws.

    Romans 13:1-7 makes it abundantly clear that God expects us to obey the laws of the government. The onlyexception to this is when a law of the government forces us to disobey a command of God (Acts 5:29). Illegal immigration is the breaking of a government’s law. There is nothing in Scripture that contradicts the idea of a sovereign nation having immigration laws. Therefore, it is rebellion against God to unlawfully enter another country. Illegal immigration is a sin.
    Illegal immigration is definitely a controversial issue in the United States (and some other countries) today. Some argue that the immigration laws are unfair, unjust, and even discriminatory-thus giving individuals justification to immigrate illegally. However, Romans 13:1-7 does not give any permission to violate a law just because it is perceived as unjust. Again, the issue is not the fairness of a law. The only biblical reason to violate a government’s law is if that law violates God's Word. When Paul wrote the book of Romans, he was under the authority of the Roman Empire, led by Emperor Nero. Under that reign, there were many laws that were unfair, unjust, and/or blatantly evil. Still, Paul instructed Christians to submit to the government.
    Are the immigration laws of the United States unfair or unjust? Some think so, but that is not the issue. All developed countries in the world have immigration laws, some more strict than the USA’s, and some less strict, and all have to deal with illegal immigration. There is nothing in the Bible to prohibit a country from having completely open borders or to have completely closed borders. Romans 13:1-7 also gives the government the authority to punish lawbreakers. Whether the punishment is imprisonment, deportation, or even something more severe, it is within the rights of the government to determine.
    Illegal immigration is a complex issue. The vast majority of illegal immigrants in the United States have come for the purpose of having a better life, providing for their families, and escaping poverty. These are good goals and motivations. However, it is not biblical to violate a law to achieve a “good.” Caring for the poor, orphans, and widows is something the Bible commands us to do (Galatians 2:10; James 1:27; 2:2-15). However, the biblical fact that we are to care for the unfortunate does not mean we should violate the law in doing so. Supporting, enabling, and/or encouraging illegal immigration is, therefore, a violation of God’s Word. Those seeking to emigrate to another country should always obey the immigration laws of that country. While this may cause delays and frustrations, it is better than acting illegally. A frustrating law is still a law.
    What is the biblical solution to illegal immigration? Simple-don’t do it; obey the laws. If disobedience is not a biblical option, what can be done in regards to an unjust immigration law? It is completely within the rights of citizens to seek to change immigration laws. If it is your conviction that an immigration law is unjust, do everything that is legally within your power to get the law changed: pray, petition, vote, peacefully protest, etc. As Christians, we should be the first to seek to change any law that is unjust. At the same time, we are also to demonstrate our submission to God by obeying the government He has placed in authority over us.
    “Be subject for the Lord’s sake to every human institution, whether it be to the emperor as supreme, or to governors as sent by him to punish those who do evil and to praise those who do good. For this is the will of God, that by doing good you should put to silence the ignorance of foolish people. Live as people who are free, not using your freedom as a cover-up for evil, but living as servants of God” (1 Peter 2:13-16).

  • Brandon Cameron
    Brandon Cameron ヶ月 前

    If word gets around the community that if you break the law the police will try to arrest you? Shocking I bet the police don't enforce the laws than any other country in the world